I received a comment I just had to respond to in a separate post. It goes like this and is in response to my “Why Do People Think I Care about The Primaries” post in which I talked about my Libertarian Party alliance.
“A Libertarian may be able to vote for local candidates and may occasionally have a vote in congress but by not supporting a main party you will basically be throwing your votes to the wind and in some cases like one I remember a few years back, a third party can help get a lousy candidate elected by splitting the vote. Do we really want that to happen again? Research the candidates. We all have an opinion and the right to support the candidate we feel is best but please before you make a decision do research on every candidate and look at them at all angles. Do not just trust main stream news media to pick your candidate or give you all of the information. We have a problem with fighting among congress right now. We need to elect a candidate that is most likely to bring the parties together and get congress working together.”
I can’t even begin to describe how totally illogical these kind of comments really are. If it were true that by some divine right we could only have two major parties our country would look a lot different today.
First we would still be choosing between the Federalist and the Anti-Federalist, and none of our modern parties would have ever existed….because they used to be a third party at one point or another. The list of successful “alternative” parties goes on and on! There were the Wigs and the Democratic/Republicans both of which held the presidency on more then one occasion. Even those parties/groups that failed to take the government had enough power to change the course of this country. Groups like the Anti-Masonic, Progressive, Temperance Movement, Civil rights, and of course the Reformists of the 1990’s… all made a huge impact on how this country has evolved. Some even forced the “main stream” parties to drastically change their stance to remain relevant. Indeed without third parties our major political realignments would have never happened.
Third Parties being popular are a giant red flag that the main parties have failed their people. They show discontent and anger. Sometimes like in the years of the Great Depression the main parties listen and they make changes, don’t forget that the idea of Democrats being liberal is less then 80 years old. Also sometimes the discontent makes a multitude of third parties that coalesce into a single new entity, Thats how we got the GOP less then 150 years ago or so. The GOP is “The Party of Lincoln” and started out as a liberal party that housed discontents from all over the the political map, but most of its power came from the several third parties and party remnants that it absorbed.
So now we come back to this comment. First and fore most I am not “throwing my vote to the wind”, I’m sending a message. I want the main parties to fall on their face, I want people like Bush to get elected so they can show how backward our political system really is, and most of all I WANT THEIR TO BE A SPOILER because I don’t want either “side” in power. Honestly does anyone really think Al Gore or John Kerry are less incompetent then Bush? I am not going to vote out of fear of who might win, but rather vote my conscience and know that I stayed true to myself. Most Americans lack the moral fiber to make the distinction, and it would make the founders sick.
Now, as far as I’m concerned there are really only two reasons someone makes the “spoiler” or “split vote” comment:
1. It’s a tactic by a main party loyalist to scare people into voting for their substandard candidate, it’s intentional, and in the case of Ralph Nader it worked. But no one that jumped ship on Nader thought twice about how they were being manipulated by the dim witted Al Gore camp because they needed votes due to the fact that he ran a horrible campaign, debated like and undergrad and a State College and not the Vice President, and of course made the fatal mistake of under estimating his opponent. Al Gore deserved to lose, and shame on the people that bought in to this tactic. Politics is a dark art and you have to be ready to stand your ground when spells like this one are cast.
2. The person saying it has no clue what they are talking about and is just repeating the programed responses that parents, the church, friends, coworkers, and of course the media ingrained into their head. For these people please wake up and think for yourself for once, or at least stop voting.
I actually have respect for the first group because being able to control peoples decisions with nothing more then rhetoric and your wits is just an amazing feet.
Finally the whole “Research the candidates. We all have an opinion and the right to support the candidate we feel is best but please before you make a decision do research on every candidate and look at them at all angles.” part of the comment I will say this:
Actually I have researched the candidates and because of my beliefs I am very disappointed, with the exception of Ron Paul. Now if Ron Paul by some miracle gets nominated I’ll vote for him, but I’m not jumping parties to make it happen. Further, I’m a Libertarian there fore no big government Democrat is ever going to get my vote. Democrats don’t even give voice to Libertarian issues, especially the ones running this cycle. As for the GOP my party EXISTS do to discontent within the GOP ranks. Back in the 70’s what we now call “Reagan Republicans” started courting the religious right and became took over the party. Along the way they abandoned the ideas of Small Government, States Rights, Individual Liberty, Low Taxes, and a Notion of non-interference in foreign governments….oh and they also used followed the Constitution. Sure they still talk about these things, but they do something much different once they are in office. Really Ron Paul (a Former Libertarian that was our party nominee in 198
is the last throws of real conservatism left in the GOP, a party now populated by Bible Thumping Freaks, Neo-cons, and Fascists. Thats why I think It’s time to let someone new try their hand, sticking with the status quo only guarantees failure.