The Wars
November 17, 2007Normally I try to avoid writing about the various conflicts the U.S. (my wonderful country) is involved with because it seems like everything that could be covered about them pretty much has. Indeed, I’ve become numb to the war coverage. That said its not because wars don’t matter to me it has more to do with the fact that the press just seems to rehash the same five stories over and over.
Since the beginning I have not necessarily been against the war, but rather I’ve been critical of the tactics. Anyone that honestly thinks the world isn’t better off without Saddam and the Taliban really has rocks for brains. That said our government seems totally inept in managing a successful war.
I keep seeing the price tag going up an up with little to no results. Our solders can’t do it alone, we learned that in Somalia. There needs to be a political solution, mediation, and UN involvement. We can’t deliver chaos to stability without a stable government in Iraq and a strong Afghani military so they can fend for themselves.
So much focus has been put on the price tag and the loss of life, this is to be expected after all these are wars. Wars are never cheap, just be glad we are not rationing needed supplies like fuel and rubber. As for the loss of life unfortunately solders die and put their lives on the line all the time. This is why we have holidays like Veterans Day and build monuments to them, and they deserve it and more for having the courage to fight for all of us.
This aside I consider myself a tactician and from that viewpoint things look bad. We have an all volunteer military that hasn’t achieved recruiting goals in I don’t know how long despite a lowering of standards on the ASVAB (thats the military entrance test). Furthermore with the 9/11 commissions findings being instated as well as new boarder security measures it is clear the National Guard is needed at home to fight the onslaught of illegal immigration, never mind the wider “War on Terror” like trying to shut down Osama Bin Laden. Tactically speaking fighting a war on multiple fronts is just plain stupid. With this half hazard management it is no wonder Army desertion is up 42% in the past year. Without strong leaders for our people and troops to follow things seem more hopeless then they really are. We are not quite to Vietnam levels yet…yet, but we are getting there quick.
In a prefect world we would have followed the Constitution when we decided to invade two sovereign nations. We would have declared war and with it all the check and balances of waging war would have come with it. Things like a Secretary of War and a War Cabinet, special tactical analysis’s which would have included stated goals, measures of success, and an exit strategy. Of course most of all a declaration of war would have given much needed oversight and many rights and benefits to the solders that they haven’t seen since WWII. But we didn’t do that because we have a megalomaniac for a President and a bunch of yellow cowards in Congress. The question now is “what do we do now?”.
We’ve been dealt a pretty bad hand and I am very concerned that the people in charge in both the White House and Congress are more concerned with an election a year away then our problems today, but Ill keep hanging on to hope.
The bottom line is we need to prioritize our goals, its triage time. There needs to be multilateral talks mediated by the UN on Iraq, and we need to come up with realistic and attainable goals for that conflict. Pulling out would be irresponsible but we do need say a two year time line. Afghanistan needs to commit to defending it’s self and we need to commit to keeping them well supplied, further we need to double our covert efforts in the mountainous region that the Taliban and others are hiding in.
It is clear we need troops, and we need to do it without a draft. The logical course is to pull out of Japan and other European locations dating back to WWII, also we need to be more conservative about where we send peace keeping troops. Once Japan has taken the reigns for its military they should take a partnership role with South Korea and we should pull out of the 38th parallel. That would probably free up another 50-70 thousand troops. Recruitment wise we need better incentives for joining the full-time military not the Guard, things like debt forgiveness or grants for purchasing houses (both have been done in the past). Another good recruiting tactic that this country has used in pretty much every previous was is to offer non-violent criminals a option of military service instead of jail time. Since we are so tough on drugs i bet there are a bunch of people caught with an ounce or two that are doing 7 to 10 that would rather do 5 in the military. Besides it would be a good way for some individuals to turn their lives around.
War involves tough choices, and to remain realistic. Our government hasn’t been good at either lately. Whats more concerning is that many people both in the government and on the civilian side are pushing for a strait up pull out, but they forget the reason things are so bad now is because we made promises and pulled out once before. Pulling out now would make Iran the regional leader which is certainly not preferable. I agree with Ron Paul that we need a noninterventionalist foreign policy but only in the future. We’ve made commitments and promises and we need to honor them and be smarter about what we commit to in the future.
Posted by Tired Rambler






